The Front Porch Dilemma

A few nights ago, I was thinking about what I could add or change to my front porch fall decor.  Mums are a big part of fall, but I didn't want to add mums to the look because I've had mums on my front porch for the last 7 fall seasons.  After pouring through a few design websites, I decided to remove the boxwood balls and add pumpkins and leaf vines to the planters.  So, this is what it looks like now:

I still like this look better:

What do you think?